Google Wifi vs Orbi vs Eero vs Linksys vs AmpliFi HD

[et_pb_section fb_built=”1″ _builder_version=”3.0.47″ custom_padding=”0|0px|0px|0px|false|false”][et_pb_row custom_padding=”0|0px|27px|0px|false|false” _builder_version=”3.0.48″ background_size=”initial” background_position=”top_left” background_repeat=”repeat”][et_pb_column type=”4_4″ _builder_version=”3.0.47″ parallax=”off” parallax_method=”on”][et_pb_text admin_label=”Overview” _builder_version=”3.15″]

Does your Wi-Fi connection start to creep as you add more devices to the network? Or better still, are you trying to extend your Wi-Fi coverage to include your entire living space �including your backyard?

There are so many Wi-Fi systems available for you to choose from today; and the one thing they all have in common is high speed and a seamless network connection, as they all share the same SSID. These systems include Google Wi-Fi, EERO, Linksys Velop, AmpliFi HD, and Netgear Orbi.

Let’s find out how each one works and which is more suitable for you to build a smooth home network.

Wi-Fi System technical details comparison

Let’s compare the technical details of each system. Don’t be too concerned with any jargon right now. We’ll explain it in the next sections.

Tech comparison table

Google WiFi eero Pro Netgear Orbi(RBK50) Amplifi HD linksys velop
Unit 3 Units

1 eeros

2 beacon

1 router

1 satellite

1 router

2 satellite

3 Unit

Max coverage

(square feet)

4,500 4,000 5,000 20,000 6,000
Max throughput 1.2 Gbps 2.1Gbps 3 Gbps 1.75 Gbps 2.1Gbps
Network standards 802.11 b/g/n/ac 802.11 b/g/n/ac 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac 802.11 b/g/n/ac
Router standard AC1200 AC2100 AC3000 AC1750 AC2200
Max link rate 2.4G 300 Mbps 300 Mbps 400 Mbps 450Mbps 400 Mbps
Max link rate 5G 867 Mbps

channel#1:867 Mbps

channel#2:867 Mbps

channel#1:867 Mbps

channel#2:1733 Mbps

1300 Mbps

channel#1:867 Mbps

channel#2:867 Mbps

Parental controls Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ports 1x Wan, 1x LAN 1x Wan, 1x LAN 1x Wan, 3x LAN for router, 4x LAN for satellite 1 x Ethernet,1 x WAN, 4 x LAN 2 x auto-sensing r WAN/LAN
Security WEP, WPA, WPA2-PSK WPA2, NAT, VPN, UPnP WEP,WPA,WPA2,WPS WPA2-PSK AES/TKIP WPA2
Weight 11.99 oz 8.5 oz 27.04 oz

Router: 14.46 oz

Satellite: 7.90 oz

17 oz
WiFi bands dual-band 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz tri-band 2.4GHz and two 5 GHz tir-band 2.4 GHz and two 5 GHz dual-band 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz tir-band 2.4 GHz and two 5 GHz
Antennas: External No No No Yes No
Beamforming Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
USB No 1x USB 2.0  No 1 x USB 2.0 No
Dimensions 4.17 x 2.66 in 4.8 x 1.2 x 4.8 in 6.67x 2.36 x 8.89 in Router: 3.91 x 3.85 x 3.92 in 3.1 x 3.1 x 7.3 in
MU-MIMO No 2×2 2×2 2×2 2×2
Work with Alexa No Yes Yes  No Yes
List price $299 $399 $369.99 $349.99 $499.97
check price on amazon amazon amazon amazon amazon

Notation

Some connected devices do not support MU-MIMO. This can make a big difference, especially with newer smartphones, such as the iPhone 7/8/x and the Samsung S7, as they are typically MIMO 2×2 client devices.

To learn more how to calculate the download speed for your spec device, along with further technical details, you can review this article. You can use the formula in the article to find the estimated speed at which your devices download data.

 WiFi download speed field test

Below are the results of a download speed test for frequencies under 5GHz, within a range of 5 and 150 feet in open place.

  AmpliFi HD Eero Google Wifi Linksys Velop Netgear Orbi RBK50
5 feet 368.17 573.65 464.36 412.34 552.11
15 feet 377.73 450.96 440.9 527.1 510.9
2.60% -21% -5.10% 30% -7.50%
50 feet 350.83 449.87 389.74 459.35 447.13
-4.70% -22% -16% 11% -19%
100 feet 293.82 250.27 227.22 330.06 371.42
-20% -56% -51% -20% -33%
150 feet 230.86 229.85 33.79 288.42 229.07
-37% -60% -93% -30% -58%

Caution:

The data just a reference for download speed, those WiFi products may have different performance in room, it depends on building structure and where your place it.

Dual-Band or Tri-Band

A tri-band router isn’t necessarily faster than a dual-band. It is, however, able to support a wider range of devices without compromising on the network speed.

 

Google Wi-Fi Mesh System

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_video src=”https://youtu.be/z7PPYNs5Xao” _builder_version=”3.6″][/et_pb_video][et_pb_text admin_label=”Google WiFi” _builder_version=”3.6″]

Google Wi-Fi is an easy-setup, easy-to-use system for the average person. This system creates a mesh network. Once you have multiple points set up throughout the house, you will be able to get a strong and reliable network connection from virtually anywhere in your house.

Google Wi-Fi uses the Network Assist Technology software. This is a built-in software program that automatically determines the best Wi-Fi connection for you. Once you are moving around the house, the Network Assist software automatically connects your device to the nearest Wi-Fi point to enable a faster connection. It will also connect your device to the fastest band available, depending on your location.

Things you can do with the Google Wi-Fi app.

  • Easily set up the Google Wi-Fi system in a couple of minutes
  • Set a priority device for faster speeds whenever you need it most
  • Control the Wi-Fi system on your kidsâ€?devices
  • See what’s connected to your network and the bandwidth you are using
  • Build a different network for guests
  • Do a network check to test connection speed
  • Adjust your settings, including network name and Wi-Fi password
  • Add a network manager, which will help you monitor your network

Pros

1200 square feet coverage per Unit

A single unit covers up to 1200 square feet with a strong signal. While moving around your house, the app will switch you seamlessly from one Wi-Fi point to the next. The app has a feature that allows it to prioritize one device above others for a specific amount of time. This is ideal for network-heavy activities, such as streaming 4K content. It also offers a parental control feature.

Very reliable in metropolitan apartments that have congested Wi-Fi bandwidth

In the designated area, Google WiFi have a very stable WiFi signal even there is a lot of other WiFi networks are nearby.

It has a simple, nearly automatic setup

The Google Wi-Fi app simplifies the network setup. After downloading the app, you’ll need to scan the QR code at the bottom of the Wi-Fi point. This will form a secure connection with your phone and the device. The next step is simply for you to enter your username and password, and let the app do the rest for you in the background.

The smart features prevent a crowded network and handles complex settings

Google Wi-Fi uses the Network Assist software to deliver the best possible connection. It does this by automatically connecting your device to the nearest possible Wi-Fi point for the fastest connection. Also, it automatically connects your device to the fastest band available in your location.

The app and firmware are regularly updated

There is always exists some potential vulnerabilities in your WiFi network system,so a frequently  upgraded firmware can keep your network safe in most of cases.

 

Cons

The app has limited management abilities and few advanced features

The app doesn’t support simple features, such as changing your network’s IP range. Also, the app doesn’t properly present the features, and you could end up spending a lot of time searching for a feature that might not be available.

You need a Google account and mobile device to set up the app

Setting up the Google Wi-Fi app requires either an Android or IOS mobile device, along with a Google account because there is no web-based interface.

Once you have lost your internet connection, you have very limited access to settings and management options

It falls short with some advanced networking features, though, including dedicated port forwarding. The major drawback with this setup is what will happen if you lose your internet connection �your access to the settings is very restricted because they are tied to your Google account online.

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_code _builder_version=”3.17.3″][aawp box=”B01MAW2294″ template=”table”][/et_pb_code][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.17.3″]

EERO Pro (2nd Generation)

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_video src=”https://youtu.be/YysjcLqinHs” _builder_version=”3.6″][/et_pb_video][et_pb_text admin_label=”EERO Pro” _builder_version=”3.6″]

The EERO Pro or the EERO 2nd Generation is the successor of the EERO 1st Generation. Similar to the Orbi, the EERO Pro is a true tri-band mesh system that operates on a 2.4GHz frequency and two 5GHz frequencies. This allows the EERO to support more devices than a dual-band system.

In addition to offering fast Wi-Fi connections, EERO also offers Bluetooth LE 4.2 technology as well as Thread radios. Thread radios are creating opportunities for EERO to develop as a hub in the home for the wider Internet of Things: controlling smart locks, light bulbs, thermostats and many more devices without the need for third-party hubs. Currently, there are not many devices available that rely on a low-power Thread. EERO, however, maintains that the reason devices are not available is that manufacturers have all been waiting for the right router to come along.

Pros

Simple, secure setup through the EERO app

Simple setup was among EERO’s goals from the beginning, but this new system is even simpler. You can do everything through the app. The EERO app will guide you through the installation process for the first router.

The process mainly involves plugging the device into your modem and powering it up. Afterward, you will wait for around 30 seconds for the modem to identify it and then tell it where in your home it is located. The EERO app gathers some basic information for final setup, including building layout, the length of the building, and the number of floors present. You have the option to name each router based on where you put it.

Good Wi-Fi range

This device has a Wi-Fi range of 120 feet, which is twice the range of a traditional router. It also offers connection speeds up to 5 times faster at similar distances. The companion app assists you with placing the routers in the best possible locations for optimal signal strength. This could even give you the opportunity to play video games from your treehouse while your router is in the basement.

Transplant capability

By purchasing one or two of these devices, you can optimize your already existing network, or replace it altogether. It works with various network adapters, thus giving you more options.

Thread and Bluetooth support

Although the EERO Beacon isn’t nearly as advanced as the regular-sized device, it still comes equipped with Thread and Bluetooth support. It has a dual-band Wi-Fi system but doesn’t have Ethernet ports. This is a considerable disadvantage if you want to connect your TV or gaming console to the device.

 

Cons

Very few Ethernet ports available

The router has only one Ethernet port, and the beacons have none

You need a smartphone for setup

EERO also comes with a companion app that you can use to manage your network. It allows you to track internet speed, monitor your network while you are away from home, and set up usage schedules for other members of the household.

Without an EERO plus subscription, you have access to very limited features

EERO offers an EERO plus service. The purpose of this service is to help keep your family’s personal data, devices, and network safe from threats. This eliminates the need to purchase safety software on individual devices, which kids can sometimes bypass rather easily, or might not work on many devices. If you have already purchased the product, then the $99/year subscription fee works out financially.

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_code _builder_version=”3.17.3″][aawp box=”B071DWXLYL” template=”table”][/et_pb_code][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.17.3″]

Netgear Orbi

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_video src=”https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-IgLQJFj0U” _builder_version=”3.6″][/et_pb_video][et_pb_text admin_label=”Netgear Orbi” _builder_version=”3.6″ text_font=”||||||||”]

The Netgear Orbi’s network is of a star topology. This means that it has one main router, and all other satellites must communicate through this router. Satellite to satellite communication is not possible. It is a tri-band system that will cover your entire home, both indoors and outdoors, with a single Wi-Fi network. This tri-band system allows you to add various devices to the network without compromising network speed.

If you are adamant about getting the highest speed Wi-Fi system, then the Orbi is undoubtedly the best choice for you. This system has a web interface that allows you to login easily and manage your settings. Once logged in, it will direct you to the already familiar Netgear setup page. This gives you access to some advanced features unique to this system, such as QoS and Forwarding.

There are some notable downsides to this system, however: namely, the sheer bulkiness of a single unit and the cost. A single Orbi unit is easily three times the size of any other single unit on this list. Not to mention, a three-pack costs around $300, with an additional $200 for extra satellites. The satellites do extend your network by 2500 sq. ft., though, so they very well might be worth it, depending on the size of your home or property.

Pros

Optimal Performance

This tri-band AC300 device has amazing performance speeds. Theoretically, it can deliver speeds of up to 400Mbps on its 2.4GHz band, 866Mbps on its 5GHz band and up to 1733Mbps on its second 5GHz band. Under real-life conditions, the Orbi router performs at a speed of up to 480Mbps, and the satellite at 470Mbps. At a 30-foot distance, the router performs at 223Mbps and the satellite at 220Mbps.

One way Orbi aims to maximize performance is by using a separate 5GHz band for communication between the router and the satellite. Other Wi-Fi extenders use the same band for signal extension and communication between devices, and this leads to a 50% signal loss each time you extend the signal wirelessly.

Wide Coverage

The Netgear Orbi Wi-Fi system has area coverage of up to 6000 square feet. As a standalone, the router covers up to 2000 square feet. Adding just one satellite can increase that coverage by another 2000 square feet, and it is possible to add yet another extender, bringing the total coverage up to around 6000 square feet. Ideally, you would place your router as close as possible to your ISP’s modem, and then add the extender where it’s most needed.

Orbi Outdoor Satellite Add-On Option

The Orbi outdoor satellite option allows you to stay connected even outdoors �rain or shine. It is the only weatherproof outdoor Wi-Fi mesh system available, and it extends coverage by up to 2500 square feet.

Simple Setup

You can easily configure the Orbi in just a few simple steps. All you have to do is turn on the main router and then download the Orbi app. After that, you follow a few basic instructions. Once setup is complete, all you need to do is find the best location to place the satellite for optimal coverage. You don’t need to concern yourself with connecting the main router and satellite as it does this automatically.

Cons

Much bulkier and heavier than similar products

The router or extender are heavier than other competitions,and the design is not so elegant as Google WiFi or eero Pro is.

A single satellite is very expensive

If it turns out that one pair of satellites is not giving you enough coverage, then prepare to pay a large sum for an extra one.

Setup can be confusing at first due to the many different options available

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_code _builder_version=”3.17.3″][aawp box=”B01K4CZOBS” template=”table”][/et_pb_code][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.17.3″]

AmpliFi HD

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_video src=”https://youtu.be/rMd_Aq_VTrc” _builder_version=”3.6″][/et_pb_video][et_pb_text admin_label=”AmpliFi HD” _builder_version=”3.6″]

One unique feature of the AmpliFi HD is that it has an LED screen that displays your current router speed. Each of its satellites also has a large antenna on its exterior on a swivel. This could become very problematic when you wish to plug it in an outlet in a small space.

While we are on the topic of settings, it is worthwhile to note that the AmpliFi HD offers more advanced settings than both Google Wi-Fi and EERO, but not as many as the Orbi. For the average home user, it is a decent system, especially if you have a dedicated media server or something similar.

Pros

Have a touchscreen, no smartphone or app is required

The others on the list are also missing a cool factor. The touchscreen display on the AmpliFi also monitors network speed and displays the time (you turn it on or off). This adds to the functionality of the AmpliFi as in a home or office, it can double as a clock; this is in addition to giving you access to some user settings.

It has 5GB Ethernet ports on the base, just like a regular router

It give a great convenience for wired connect device,sometimes we still need use CAT 5 to connect printer or smart TV.

Wide coverage area and optimal speed

With a combination of one base router and two satellites, the AmpliFi HD covers an impressively wide area of up to 20,000 square feet. Theoretically, it offers speeds of up to 5.25Gbps �1.75Gbps from each of the two satellites and 1.75Gbps from the router.

Our testing has shown that signals extend even further down the street than we thought possible. For many of us, that’s reason enough to make the purchase. You might even be able to receive great signal strength in your outbuildings, or share Wi-Fi with your neighbors. One reason this is possible is that of the satellite setup. Each one is a tall, two-piece wand that you need to plug into an outlet, as opposed to just a tiny device meant to sit on a table.

Solid installation

Another factor to keep in mind with the AmpliFi HD is that it’s not exactly childproof. Since the units are usually plugged into your home outlets and have an interesting design, it is very easy for a curious kid to notice and have access to it.

Each two-piece unit is held together by strong magnets, which means it won’t harm someone pulling on the antennas. Still, it’s best to keep your kids away from electrical outlets if possible. For those of you who don’t have kids wandering around, you might enjoy the look of this one.

Cons

Extremely large satellites that require mounting on a wall outlet

No Ethernet ports on satellites

Some might find the satellites less visually appealing than those of the competition

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_code _builder_version=”3.17.3″][aawp box=”B01L9O08PW” template=”table”][/et_pb_code][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.17.3″]

Linksys Velop

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_video src=”https://youtu.be/sJ7U-00Thkg” _builder_version=”3.6″][/et_pb_video][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.6″ background_size=”initial” background_position=”top_left” background_repeat=”repeat”]

The Linksys Velop is similar to the EERO and Google Wi-Fi in that it is available as a single unit, in pairs, or in packs of three. You have the freedom to add up to 10 Velop devices into your system. And the best part is that you will only have one Wi-Fi name and password to remember. With this large number of nodes, you will be able to roam around your area easily without ever losing your connection.

Linksys equipped each node with 2 Ethernet ports, a switch (on/off), and a reset button. And any node can be used to connect to your modem. Additionally, you can use the ports on the second node as a hard-wired connection for game consoles or desktop computers. According to Linksys, once the configuration is complete, each node provides coverage for an area of size 2000 square feet. It does not, however, contain USB ports, so there’s no way to connect a printer.

Something to note about the Velop devices is that they each have a ZigBee radio hidden inside them for home automation purposes. They are not active at the moment though. According to a Linksys representative we spoke with, the company is working on enabling the radio.

Pros

Sleek design

Simple configuration and management

User-friendly

 

Cons

Minimal Ethernet ports

No USB port

Costly 

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_code _builder_version=”3.17.3″][aawp box=”B01N2NLNEH” template=”table”][/et_pb_code][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.17.3″]

 Verdict

All in all, the mesh and star topology systems mentioned above impress us with their performance when compared to a single router network; they offer great Wi-Fi speeds, and they give you the option to add many devices without compromising signal quality or speed.

If you are looking for something that you can configure easily, that has all the most popular features, and that the company is constantly updating, then the Google Wi-Fi might be for you. Something to keep in mind is that Google collects some of your usage information to improve their system. You can find more details in their privacy policy.

If you want something on the higher end with all the most advanced features and that you can configure easily, then the Netgear Orbi is for you.

For those of you looking for high speed, simple set up, and more specific features (such as support thread or touchscreen), then you might want to look into getting either the EERO Pro, AmpliFi HD, or the Linksys Velop. Each of these offers higher speeds than the Google Wi-Fi system, although they are still no match for the Orbi in 5GHz.

If you use Amazon Alexa products at home, then you might want to keep this in mind when choosing a Wi-Fi system.

[/et_pb_text][et_pb_divider _builder_version=”3.17.3″][/et_pb_divider][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.17.3″]

Related articles you might like:

Mesh WiFi Network �All things you need to know

Wireless Network for Smart Home

WiFi Extender

[/et_pb_text][/et_pb_column][/et_pb_row][/et_pb_section]

Author: